Mafia Online
Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.

Nerdfighter Mafia

+19
whoviancrochet
AppleZach
Lkun
DecemberHare
MunchyDumpling
boxtop
partinobodycular
shad0wkissed
frostehh
Skylar
MLPAlex
Sawybean1
Statefarm
Cat
saturnlite88
PinkSponge
Matt
speckleasme
Mary
23 posters

Page 2 of 24 Previous  1, 2, 3 ... 13 ... 24  Next

Go down

Nerdfighter Mafia - Page 2 Empty Re: Nerdfighter Mafia

Post by Matt Thu Dec 27, 2012 3:21 pm

If you look at past games, Saturn has killed Blake before because he has some sort of jealousy issue with him. (Doctor Who game) Since Blake is sitting this game out, it is certainly possible Saturn switched his target to Sergio since he doesn't like him much either.
Matt
Matt
Hooker
Hooker

Posts : 410
Points : 628

Back to top Go down

Nerdfighter Mafia - Page 2 Empty Re: Nerdfighter Mafia

Post by Mary Thu Dec 27, 2012 3:25 pm

Voting for Saturnlite88
Matt
Mary
Mary
Hitman
Hitman

Posts : 2132
Points : 1841

Back to top Go down

Nerdfighter Mafia - Page 2 Empty Re: Nerdfighter Mafia

Post by PinkSponge Thu Dec 27, 2012 3:36 pm

That doesn't make sense. It wasn't a jealousy thing with Blake, Saturn just wanted a good player out of the way first. It almost seems like you're trying to throw suspicion onto Saturn because of a grudge. He hasn't even gotten a chance to say anything yet.
PinkSponge
PinkSponge
Informant
Informant

Posts : 1453
Points : 1637

Back to top Go down

Nerdfighter Mafia - Page 2 Empty Re: Nerdfighter Mafia

Post by Statefarm Thu Dec 27, 2012 3:37 pm

This is the same reasoning Saturn used last game against Cat that Matt (I really like how your names rhyme) repeatedly said was stupid.
Statefarm
Statefarm
Informant
Informant

Posts : 1341
Points : 1731

Back to top Go down

Nerdfighter Mafia - Page 2 Empty Re: Nerdfighter Mafia

Post by MLPAlex Thu Dec 27, 2012 3:42 pm

so Wait, matt Said the reasoning Was stupid
the Started Using it?
MLPAlex
MLPAlex
Informant
Informant

Posts : 1179
Points : 1453

Back to top Go down

Nerdfighter Mafia - Page 2 Empty Re: Nerdfighter Mafia

Post by Matt Thu Dec 27, 2012 3:43 pm

"Just for future reference, this is a lie. He was supposed to be a traitor in game 10, but something happened the first night that ruined that and he was upset about not being able to betray me (he even told me that) and now the next game he's mafia and chooses to kill me the first night. Plus saturn and I always have a mafia grudge, whether he admits it or not." -Blake, in the doctor who dead thread thing

I agree that it's horrible logic but when it concerns the death of my two best friends (you're not one of them Taylor) I am going to try any approach I can to avenge them. Seriously though, there is nothing else to go on so I'm trying this to see how it works. Is that okay?

Oh, and last game when I said it was stupid logic for Saturn to use, I was mafia so I don't see how it applies. I think it works better here since we can at least be pretty sure that Saturn does use real life grudges when it comes to mafia.
Matt
Matt
Hooker
Hooker

Posts : 410
Points : 628

Back to top Go down

Nerdfighter Mafia - Page 2 Empty Re: Nerdfighter Mafia

Post by PinkSponge Thu Dec 27, 2012 3:46 pm

This situation has happened so much the past few mafia games. Someone who is known to have a bad relationship with someone else dies, and then everyone turns on the person who doesn't like them very much. I think whoever killed Sergio knew this would happen, and someone who actually didn't like Sergio would want to avoid that.
PinkSponge
PinkSponge
Informant
Informant

Posts : 1453
Points : 1637

Back to top Go down

Nerdfighter Mafia - Page 2 Empty Re: Nerdfighter Mafia

Post by Matt Thu Dec 27, 2012 3:53 pm

Why would they need to avoid it, when they can easily say "well it's happened so much, I would have to be stupid to want to do that", or some other derivative of that?
Matt
Matt
Hooker
Hooker

Posts : 410
Points : 628

Back to top Go down

Nerdfighter Mafia - Page 2 Empty Re: Nerdfighter Mafia

Post by frostehh Thu Dec 27, 2012 3:54 pm

PinkSponge wrote:This situation has happened so much the past few mafia games. Someone who is known to have a bad relationship with someone else dies, and then everyone turns on the person who doesn't like them very much. I think whoever killed Sergio knew this would happen, and someone who actually didn't like Sergio would want to avoid that.
This. My first thought was to jump to Saturn as well, but honestly I think he's smarter than that. He definitely knows he would be the first looked at if Sergio died, so I highly doubt he would put himself in that kind of position.
frostehh
frostehh
Informant
Informant

Posts : 1186
Points : 1822

Back to top Go down

Nerdfighter Mafia - Page 2 Empty Re: Nerdfighter Mafia

Post by PinkSponge Thu Dec 27, 2012 3:56 pm

We're kind of getting into "well-they-know-I-don't-want-that-so-I'll-do-it-but-then-they'll-think-I-will-do-that-because-I-know-they-know-I-don't-want-it" and so on and so forth. For now, let's stop arguing over Saturn based on a bad relationship and wait for him to actually come and weigh in on it.
PinkSponge
PinkSponge
Informant
Informant

Posts : 1453
Points : 1637

Back to top Go down

Nerdfighter Mafia - Page 2 Empty Re: Nerdfighter Mafia

Post by Statefarm Thu Dec 27, 2012 4:00 pm

I can tell you exactly what Saturn is going to say since we're the best of friends and know each other so well.

"This is stupid. I don't base things that happen in games on real life feelings and if I did, I wouldn't be stupid enough to kill Sergio when people know I don't like him. I'm suspicious of Matt for using the logic he said was so stupid against me because it's stupid. I'm not stupid. You're stupid."

Except he'd probably say "your stupid" because he doesn't know how to correctly use the different forms.


Last edited by Statefarm on Thu Dec 27, 2012 4:09 pm; edited 1 time in total (Reason for editing : Let's fight, Jessica.)
Statefarm
Statefarm
Informant
Informant

Posts : 1341
Points : 1731

Back to top Go down

Nerdfighter Mafia - Page 2 Empty Re: Nerdfighter Mafia

Post by Statefarm Thu Dec 27, 2012 4:01 pm

Basically, while I don't really agree with Matt, waiting for Saturn to come in and say something isn't going to do much. He's not just going to say, "oh if I was mafia, I would definitely kill Sergio first."
Statefarm
Statefarm
Informant
Informant

Posts : 1341
Points : 1731

Back to top Go down

Nerdfighter Mafia - Page 2 Empty Re: Nerdfighter Mafia

Post by Matt Thu Dec 27, 2012 4:03 pm

Well then Taylor, who do you suggest we look at? I remove my vote btw
Matt
Matt
Hooker
Hooker

Posts : 410
Points : 628

Back to top Go down

Nerdfighter Mafia - Page 2 Empty Re: Nerdfighter Mafia

Post by PinkSponge Thu Dec 27, 2012 4:05 pm

Statefarm seems pretty spot-on.

Although you said "I would be stupid enough" instead of "I wouldn't be stupid enough".

On that note, I vote Statefarm for confusing me with that typo.
PinkSponge
PinkSponge
Informant
Informant

Posts : 1453
Points : 1637

Back to top Go down

Nerdfighter Mafia - Page 2 Empty Re: Nerdfighter Mafia

Post by Statefarm Thu Dec 27, 2012 4:08 pm

I don't really have anyone I think we should look at. The first kill is usually random since there are a lot of people to choose from and barely anyone has said anything anyways.

In the end, we'll probably kill someone who's inactive, they'll turn out innocent and we'll end up right back where we started tomorrow because that seems to be how this usually goes. Except recently, we've decided that we're going to take outside relationships into account and I can't recall that ever working for us either.
Statefarm
Statefarm
Informant
Informant

Posts : 1341
Points : 1731

Back to top Go down

Nerdfighter Mafia - Page 2 Empty Re: Nerdfighter Mafia

Post by Mary Thu Dec 27, 2012 4:12 pm

Voting for Statefarm
Pinksponge

hehe
Mary
Mary
Hitman
Hitman

Posts : 2132
Points : 1841

Back to top Go down

Nerdfighter Mafia - Page 2 Empty Re: Nerdfighter Mafia

Post by MLPAlex Thu Dec 27, 2012 4:42 pm

Welp this is interesting.
Is this game a one day or a three game day?
Im to lazy to read the instructions .

goo
MLPAlex
MLPAlex
Informant
Informant

Posts : 1179
Points : 1453

Back to top Go down

Nerdfighter Mafia - Page 2 Empty Re: Nerdfighter Mafia

Post by Mary Thu Dec 27, 2012 4:47 pm

One day. The lynch will happen at 10pm central tonight (just over 7 hours)
Mary
Mary
Hitman
Hitman

Posts : 2132
Points : 1841

Back to top Go down

Nerdfighter Mafia - Page 2 Empty Re: Nerdfighter Mafia

Post by MLPAlex Thu Dec 27, 2012 4:57 pm

OK! Wink

I have to vote today. so i will Dante Redfield
MLPAlex
MLPAlex
Informant
Informant

Posts : 1179
Points : 1453

Back to top Go down

Nerdfighter Mafia - Page 2 Empty Re: Nerdfighter Mafia

Post by speckleasme Thu Dec 27, 2012 5:01 pm

Screw the first day, I no-vote.
speckleasme
speckleasme
Crook
Crook

Posts : 682
Points : 1078

Back to top Go down

Nerdfighter Mafia - Page 2 Empty Re: Nerdfighter Mafia

Post by MLPAlex Thu Dec 27, 2012 5:08 pm

No- I vote
MLPAlex
MLPAlex
Informant
Informant

Posts : 1179
Points : 1453

Back to top Go down

Nerdfighter Mafia - Page 2 Empty Re: Nerdfighter Mafia

Post by shad0wkissed Thu Dec 27, 2012 5:42 pm

The list of rules scares me. O_O
shad0wkissed
shad0wkissed
Scum
Scum

Posts : 28
Points : 133

Back to top Go down

Nerdfighter Mafia - Page 2 Empty Re: Nerdfighter Mafia

Post by PinkSponge Thu Dec 27, 2012 5:56 pm

It's just four rules, and the last one is something you should be doing anyway. Is there anything specific that's scary? hehe The voting rule, maybe?
PinkSponge
PinkSponge
Informant
Informant

Posts : 1453
Points : 1637

Back to top Go down

Nerdfighter Mafia - Page 2 Empty Re: Nerdfighter Mafia

Post by shad0wkissed Thu Dec 27, 2012 6:03 pm

YES. i dont want to vote an innocent! D: and the fact that i have to be here. i'm a very busy girl you know. Razz
shad0wkissed
shad0wkissed
Scum
Scum

Posts : 28
Points : 133

Back to top Go down

Nerdfighter Mafia - Page 2 Empty Re: Nerdfighter Mafia

Post by saturnlite88 Thu Dec 27, 2012 6:19 pm

If I were mafia, I would DEFIANTLY kill Sergio first. Not stupid Alex.

Matt is just being Matt. He got me voted out first last game after I accused his friend Cat and he thought it was fun so he is doing it again.

Even though he turned out to be mafia last game so my "promise" doesn't really count, I vote Alex since as of now we have no leads and he does nothing to help the town ever.
saturnlite88
saturnlite88
Admin
Admin

Posts : 1552
Points : 2129

http://mafia-town.net

Back to top Go down

Nerdfighter Mafia - Page 2 Empty Re: Nerdfighter Mafia

Post by Sponsored content


Sponsored content


Back to top Go down

Page 2 of 24 Previous  1, 2, 3 ... 13 ... 24  Next

Back to top

- Similar topics

 
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum