Mafia Online
Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.

DOCTOR WHO MAFIA

+22
Lkun
DecemberHare
RonNofar
Narrator
Blake11roys
frostehh
Matt
Sergio
speckleasme
MLPMicah
boxtop
Statefarm
lucyjoan
Cat
saturnlite88
scootalootrue
whoviancrochet
Gage NewPline
MLPAlex
AppleZach
Mary
PinkSponge
26 posters

Page 17 of 22 Previous  1 ... 10 ... 16, 17, 18 ... 22  Next

Go down

DOCTOR WHO MAFIA - Page 17 Empty Re: DOCTOR WHO MAFIA

Post by whoviancrochet Fri Nov 23, 2012 3:29 pm

You voted for me yesterday as soon as I voted for you and today you were speculating that Ron and I were conspiring together as mafia

whoviancrochet
Scum
Scum

Posts : 86
Points : -3689

Back to top Go down

DOCTOR WHO MAFIA - Page 17 Empty Re: DOCTOR WHO MAFIA

Post by MLPAlex Fri Nov 23, 2012 3:53 pm

Hey everyone,
Guess what?
I am dead
MLPAlex
MLPAlex
Informant
Informant

Posts : 1179
Points : 1453

Back to top Go down

DOCTOR WHO MAFIA - Page 17 Empty Re: DOCTOR WHO MAFIA

Post by introextravert Fri Nov 23, 2012 4:00 pm

So quick explanation as to why I have been inactive so long: I've been out of town at my cousins' house, which has no internet access whatsoever and have been black friday shopping, etc, etc.
Just proving to everyone that I'm doing my best not to be inactive anymore.

Mary wrote:Blake's sudden accusation of Saturn that doesn't have much backing makes me think #1 that Blake knew he was going to die (or at least knew he was out of regenerations so that if he was targeted he would die and he thought he would be targeted) and that #2 he might actually know something in regards to Saturn.

I agree with this. It seemed to me like he knew something was going to happen to cause his death, whether or not it was related to saturn.

introextravert
Recruit
Recruit

Posts : 11
Points : 11

Back to top Go down

DOCTOR WHO MAFIA - Page 17 Empty Re: DOCTOR WHO MAFIA

Post by saturnlite88 Fri Nov 23, 2012 4:29 pm

I'm awake now. My ear still feels very pressured.

Again, I don't think there is much basis aginst me, and I really don't want to be voted out on a "hunch" that so and so knew something. And Blake is known to take in real world grudges. That is why he tried to kill me in Superheroes and ended up brainwashing me in that game. I think that he is basing his argument on coincidences.

I'm having a hard time keeping up on the other arguments. I think Cat had a good reason to suspect Ron and Who but I'm not sure that is the right direction to go.

Thanks, Mary. I hope I do too. Especially before the game tomorrow.
saturnlite88
saturnlite88
Admin
Admin

Posts : 1552
Points : 2129

http://mafia-town.net

Back to top Go down

DOCTOR WHO MAFIA - Page 17 Empty Re: DOCTOR WHO MAFIA

Post by MLPMicah Fri Nov 23, 2012 5:04 pm

This is gonna get me killed. Im voting LucyJoan. On a hunch. I haven't seen any reason for her to defend Cat up until now. From what I can see, they haven't even conversed directly.

I WILL change my vote if really anybody makes a decent enough point.
MLPMicah
MLPMicah
Scum
Scum

Posts : 97
Points : 352

Back to top Go down

DOCTOR WHO MAFIA - Page 17 Empty Re: DOCTOR WHO MAFIA

Post by Mary Fri Nov 23, 2012 7:03 pm

Well, I'm going to vote Saturn because I think that's the best we have to go off of.
Mary
Mary
Hitman
Hitman

Posts : 2132
Points : 1841

Back to top Go down

DOCTOR WHO MAFIA - Page 17 Empty Re: DOCTOR WHO MAFIA

Post by Narrator Fri Nov 23, 2012 7:32 pm

3 and a half hours left. These people need to vote today or they will be modkilled:

Introextravert
Scoot
Sergio
Narrator
Narrator
Scum
Scum

Posts : 43
Points : 50

https://mafiaonline.forumotion.com/t62-mafia-game-ten-game-thread

Back to top Go down

DOCTOR WHO MAFIA - Page 17 Empty Re: DOCTOR WHO MAFIA

Post by AppleZach Fri Nov 23, 2012 7:35 pm

Votes

for Lucy

MLPMicah

Thats it.
AppleZach
AppleZach
Hooker
Hooker

Posts : 329
Points : 502

Back to top Go down

DOCTOR WHO MAFIA - Page 17 Empty Re: DOCTOR WHO MAFIA

Post by saturnlite88 Fri Nov 23, 2012 7:37 pm

I'm confuse. Can we have real vote tally please?
saturnlite88
saturnlite88
Admin
Admin

Posts : 1552
Points : 2129

http://mafia-town.net

Back to top Go down

DOCTOR WHO MAFIA - Page 17 Empty Re: DOCTOR WHO MAFIA

Post by partinobodycular Fri Nov 23, 2012 7:40 pm

Blake11roys wrote:I think saturn is mafia. He is somebody that I really think would kill me on the first day, especially since he was upset that he didn't get to betray me last game like he was originally supposed to. I also think he's somebody that would take the risk of killing somebody that he failed to kill the first night, and I really think the mafia attacked me night 2 and that's why they failed to kill.
This is something to consider, but as of now I'm not convinced. The mafia failed to kill because they attacked him again? That doesn't really make sense to me. There are a lot of reasons the kill could have failed - wasn't sent in, roleblocker, doctor, etc - so saying it must have been because Blake was the target again is a big assumption, and it seems farfetched to me. He might have known more than he was letting on but I guess we won't find out now un Basically there are just a lot of conclusions that I think come more from paranoia and Blake assuming other people will play the way he would (for instance, playing based on outside grudges), than any actual evidence.
partinobodycular
partinobodycular
Admin
Admin

Posts : 1509
Points : 2066

http://rayshagurlquakay.tumblr.com

Back to top Go down

DOCTOR WHO MAFIA - Page 17 Empty Re: DOCTOR WHO MAFIA

Post by Cat Fri Nov 23, 2012 7:43 pm

I'm voting for Whovian because I have work again and won't be on. She didn't really refute anything said against her, just said I was eager to put blame on those two when they voted for me first, and (I think) I had a pretty good reason to suspect them.


So yeah I vote Whovian.
Cat
Cat
Hooker
Hooker

Posts : 443
Points : 709

Back to top Go down

DOCTOR WHO MAFIA - Page 17 Empty Re: DOCTOR WHO MAFIA

Post by saturnlite88 Fri Nov 23, 2012 7:51 pm

I should vote before I leave.

Can we please get a tally??
saturnlite88
saturnlite88
Admin
Admin

Posts : 1552
Points : 2129

http://mafia-town.net

Back to top Go down

DOCTOR WHO MAFIA - Page 17 Empty Re: DOCTOR WHO MAFIA

Post by frostehh Fri Nov 23, 2012 7:55 pm

Voting for Lucyjoan:
MLPMicah

Voting for Saturn:

Mary

Voting for Whovian:
Cat
frostehh
frostehh
Informant
Informant

Posts : 1186
Points : 1822

Back to top Go down

DOCTOR WHO MAFIA - Page 17 Empty Re: DOCTOR WHO MAFIA

Post by saturnlite88 Fri Nov 23, 2012 8:10 pm

It's only those three...

Um... Well, I'm not voting for myself, and I don't follow Micah's argument. SHe said Lucy is suspicious for following Whovian, is that right?

I'm sorry guys, I don't really follow much today. I'm gonna have to vote for Whovian. Cat had a lot of reasons for her, and although I didn't really read them, I'll assume that they were smart reasons.
saturnlite88
saturnlite88
Admin
Admin

Posts : 1552
Points : 2129

http://mafia-town.net

Back to top Go down

DOCTOR WHO MAFIA - Page 17 Empty Re: DOCTOR WHO MAFIA

Post by lucyjoan Fri Nov 23, 2012 8:14 pm

OMGUS vote on Micah.
lucyjoan
lucyjoan
Admin
Admin

Posts : 1546
Points : 1677

https://facebook.com/lucyjoancrochet

Back to top Go down

DOCTOR WHO MAFIA - Page 17 Empty Re: DOCTOR WHO MAFIA

Post by whoviancrochet Fri Nov 23, 2012 8:19 pm

whoviancrochet wrote:

2. I am still quite suspicious of cat. She seems really eager to place the blame on me and Ron. Like someone said, the only innocent I voted for was lkun because I thought he was guilty. And so did other people because we had no leads at the time. Also, I did not have my phone the first day until after the day was over so I couldn't even check it otherwise I would've voted.

I said this earlier today. I defended against cats case against me that I was inactive then I voted for lkun. I have reason for being inactive and voting for lkun. So I did refute the case against me. So I don't see cats reason for voting for me because I didn't defend against the case made against me

whoviancrochet
Scum
Scum

Posts : 86
Points : -3689

Back to top Go down

DOCTOR WHO MAFIA - Page 17 Empty Re: DOCTOR WHO MAFIA

Post by whoviancrochet Fri Nov 23, 2012 8:21 pm

Oh and also saturns reasoning is basically that he trusts cat even though he isn't totally sure of her argument

whoviancrochet
Scum
Scum

Posts : 86
Points : -3689

Back to top Go down

DOCTOR WHO MAFIA - Page 17 Empty Re: DOCTOR WHO MAFIA

Post by RonNofar Fri Nov 23, 2012 8:34 pm

Saturn's behavior is making me think twice about who to vote for. You can't just trust something someone says without reading it especially if it breaks a tie. I personally think that both Saturn and cat are in cahoots with each other. I've read the thread over 3 times now and I still can't pin point it, but it just seems to me like they are suspicious.

I vote Saturn for now.
RonNofar
RonNofar
Gooney
Gooney

Posts : 127
Points : 236

Back to top Go down

DOCTOR WHO MAFIA - Page 17 Empty Re: DOCTOR WHO MAFIA

Post by saturnlite88 Fri Nov 23, 2012 8:41 pm

I didn't mean to just trust guys. I am super busy and sick and I need to go right now. I read part of it and I get the gist of it, but all I meant is that I didn't put my usually critical mind behind my vote. I need to vote though since I have one inactive, and who does seem the best vote for me. I just can't put effort into really thinking of it right now.

But there are only three votes up and one is for me, so can you blame me?
saturnlite88
saturnlite88
Admin
Admin

Posts : 1552
Points : 2129

http://mafia-town.net

Back to top Go down

DOCTOR WHO MAFIA - Page 17 Empty Re: DOCTOR WHO MAFIA

Post by AppleZach Fri Nov 23, 2012 9:09 pm

Voting for Lucyjoan:
MLPMicah

Voting for Saturn:
Mary
RonNofar

Voting for Whovian:
Cat
Saturn

Voting MLPMicah
Lucy


Last edited by AppleZach on Fri Nov 23, 2012 9:16 pm; edited 1 time in total
AppleZach
AppleZach
Hooker
Hooker

Posts : 329
Points : 502

Back to top Go down

DOCTOR WHO MAFIA - Page 17 Empty Re: DOCTOR WHO MAFIA

Post by lucyjoan Fri Nov 23, 2012 9:10 pm

You missed my vote for Micah and saturn's vote for whovian
lucyjoan
lucyjoan
Admin
Admin

Posts : 1546
Points : 1677

https://facebook.com/lucyjoancrochet

Back to top Go down

DOCTOR WHO MAFIA - Page 17 Empty Re: DOCTOR WHO MAFIA

Post by AppleZach Fri Nov 23, 2012 9:19 pm

I'm suspicious of Whovian, and Saturn, but Saturn is gonna take the vote today.

Vote Saturn
AppleZach
AppleZach
Hooker
Hooker

Posts : 329
Points : 502

Back to top Go down

DOCTOR WHO MAFIA - Page 17 Empty Re: DOCTOR WHO MAFIA

Post by partinobodycular Fri Nov 23, 2012 9:41 pm

I'm not really extremely suspicious of any of these people... hopefully there'll be a little more discussion because I'm having a hard time making my mind up right now.
partinobodycular
partinobodycular
Admin
Admin

Posts : 1509
Points : 2066

http://rayshagurlquakay.tumblr.com

Back to top Go down

DOCTOR WHO MAFIA - Page 17 Empty Re: DOCTOR WHO MAFIA

Post by PinkSponge Fri Nov 23, 2012 10:02 pm

Voting for Lucyjoan:
MLPMicah

Voting for Saturn:
Mary
RonNofar
AppleZach

Voting for Whovian:
Cat
Saturn

Voting MLPMicah
Lucy
PinkSponge
PinkSponge
Informant
Informant

Posts : 1453
Points : 1637

Back to top Go down

DOCTOR WHO MAFIA - Page 17 Empty Re: DOCTOR WHO MAFIA

Post by whoviancrochet Fri Nov 23, 2012 10:08 pm

So obviously I think cat is suspicious but for today I think I'm going to vote for Saturn. I don't like his reasoning for voting for me And it seems suspicious he automatically sided with cat.

whoviancrochet
Scum
Scum

Posts : 86
Points : -3689

Back to top Go down

DOCTOR WHO MAFIA - Page 17 Empty Re: DOCTOR WHO MAFIA

Post by Sponsored content


Sponsored content


Back to top Go down

Page 17 of 22 Previous  1 ... 10 ... 16, 17, 18 ... 22  Next

Back to top

- Similar topics

 
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum