Nerdfighter Mafia

welp i feel stupid (like always)

MLPAlex wrote:

Matt wrote:Why am I thinking Alex is gonna cause a tie at the last minute

I was tricked into it.... I thought i broke the tie!!!!! but i only caused it.

I think Matt is psychic.

He traveled back in time

Good morning, nerdfighters. It's Thursday. After the deaths this morning, Nerdfighteria Island was quite a bit less peaceful today than usual. At the end of the day, the nerdfighters surrounded Matt, or the Yeti, apparently not realizing that she was Sarah Green, John's lovely wife. The nerdfighters mourned her loss when they realized their mistake but a few deceptions in the group were happy to have her out of the way.

Matt was town. You have 12 hours to PM me.

I'm sorry for tricking you Alex. I'm a wicked person.

I accept your apology
Just dont trick me again

Sarah?!

Well, shoot.

Matt wrote:so you think speck and I are probably both innnocent, and caused a tie between us? ok. It seems that you're more eager to vote me out, considering I'm not even voting for you.

Just to be clear, you misunderstood my. I never thought you were both probably innocent. I thought that you were the most suspicious person of the day. And I'm not going to not vote for you because it would cause a tie hours before the day ended... that's stupid. We can't be afraid of causing any ties at all, just ties that will exist at the end of the day.

Me, Sergio, and Matt in one day?

This is the worst game in history


/

Good morning, nerdfighters! French the Llama today is an exciting day on Nerdfighteria Island! When everyone ventured outside this morning they discovered the body of MLPAlex, a unicorn, lying in the middle of the street. Obviously, any nerdfighter knows that unicorns are evil because they allowed Voldemort to live so this is definitely a victory for the town. World suck levels have decreased to yellow! DFTBA!

MLPAlex, a mafia member, is dead. You have 12 hours to lynch

So how did that even happen? Does someone have a role like Zach did in game 12?

Whoa...only a mafia member died? Nice!

12 was Hunger Games, right? So you think whoever was killed made someone else die? That's interesting. It's possible, but I don't know if that's the most likely explanation.

Sometimes the mafia just forgets who else is in it. *cough* Statefarm *cough*

I guess it could have been a vigilante. Or maybe it's some weird interaction of roles that just ended up with a mafia death.

Are we going to talk about the fact that it's Alex who died or have we agreed that real-world grudges don't have any bearing on the game?

Well because Alex is mafia, the mafia couldn't have killed him (right?), so that means anyone with a grudge against him is more likely to be innocent. Unless we have decided that grudges don't affect the game, then ignore everything I just said.

Well that sucks

At least i get to go back and throw a party in the dead person place. Haven t done that in 3 games

speckleasme wrote:Well because Alex is mafia, the mafia couldn't have killed him (right?), so that means anyone with a grudge against him is more likely to be innocent. Unless we have decided that grudges don't affect the game, then ignore everything I just said.

The whole grudges argument is getting really WIFOM, so I think we should just drop it for now.

And Parti didn't let Taylor kill her own mafia member last game (who happened to be Alex, actually), but in the Disney game (narrated by Taylor, as it happens), the mafia was allowed to kill their own member. So it just depends on whether Mary would allow that, but I don't think the mafia would slip up in that way.

Parti didn't kill Alex when I told her his name because she didn't think I knew what I was doing. I let Ct kill Gryndstone, I think, because I thought she did know what she was doing. (She was all like, "I want to kill Gryndstone" and I was like, "Are you sure?" and she was like, "Yes *reason* but her reason was for him being innocent but she said she was sure so I went there.)

Anyways, I don't think a vigilante is likely because then that means the mafia didn't get a kill and the vigilante couldn't have known Alex was mafia. It's too early. I think a role that has an x-shot ability to kill it's attacker or like Zach's role last game is most likely. Since there seem to be people with grudges against Alex, I wouldn't be surprised if someone chose him as their shield.

Also, I'm going to go back and find a quote but I'm pretty sure I remember Boxtop defending Alex.

boxtop wrote:I've read through the thread so far and I'm not finding anyone suspicious, including the two people being voted for. I'm concerned that people are voting for Alex because they see him as a "useless townie". First off, if the town really wants to win, we need to keep as much of us alive, regardless of playing styles.

Okay, that's not really suspicious but it's something so yay.

Also, Saturn was the first to bring up Alex and PinkSponge followed along for a little while so I think they're probably innocent.

See guys, if we had gone ahead and killed Alex yesterday, we wouldn't have lost Matt. Although, an innocent might have died today to even it out, who knows.

Taylor left out the second half of Boxtop's quote, and I think it does have some bearing on this.

boxtop wrote:In the last game that Alex wasn't mafia, he was killed the first night, and now in this game people are trying to lynch him the first day. C'mon, guys. Even if you think he's not a great player, give him a chance to improve. That's what I'm trying to do, myself.

See the thing is, he's not improving. He says so himself, that he doesn't take anything seriously, he's deliberately confusing, and yesterday he caused a tie at the very last second because he didn't pay attention. And we all just assumed (Or I did, at least) that the tie was an innocent oversight, but he could have done it maliciously. And we wouldn't have thought twice, because it's the kind of thing Alex would do. I'm not trying to be mean here, he's been playing since the MLP game, and I don't like his playing style.

Sorry

Is there no dead person discussion?