Nerdfighter Mafia

For a mafia member, I feel like his playing style works though. We all assumed he was innocent and like you said, that just seems like something Alex would do. In Deserted Island, he was literally so suspicious that we all just said, "Oh, well, he's innocent." In Hunger Games, the mafia won because of it. As a member of town, yeah, he could try to be a better player but I'd say he's pretty good at being mafia.

Mary wrote:Good morning, nerdfighters! French the Llama today is an exciting day on Nerdfighteria Island! When everyone ventured outside this morning they discovered the body of MLPAlex, a unicorn, lying in the middle of the street.

When I got this far I thought you were just being mean to Alex

Saturn and PinkSponge did seem to be in agreement yesterday, and Pink was kind of lightly defending Saturn... I don't know if that means anything. Just an observation.

MLPAlex wrote:Is there no dead person discussion?

I would think so. Mary might have just forgotten to add you but I think any admin can do so as well so if one of them is online, they should be able to do that.

MLPAlex wrote:Is there no dead person discussion?

Added

partinobodycular wrote:Saturn and PinkSponge did seem to be in agreement yesterday, and Pink was kind of lightly defending Saturn... I don't know if that means anything. Just an observation.

I was defending him in the beginning because the arguments about "he's the first person who would kill Sergio therefore he's the last person who would kill Sergio therefore he's most likely to kill Sergio" were a little ridiculous. And I obviously have my own opinions about Alex, and Saturn just happened to voice them first.

I defended Alex only because of what I already said: People were voting him out because they didn't want him either way, and I didn't like that. It's just my luck that he happened to be mafia this game, but I still stand by what I said. If people had been voting for him because they thought he actually might be mafia and not because they just didn't like him as a player, I wouldn't have needed to defend him or explain how I felt like he was being bullied.

partinobodycular wrote:

MLPAlex wrote:Is there no dead person discussion?

Added

Sorry! Right after I posted the narration a dog arrived at my house (I'm dog sitting this weekend ) so I kind of forgot everything I needed to do.

I knew I forgot something important! I have to catch up on what happened!

Welp this is an interesting game. I hope yall realize I was the one helping keep this game alive. Without my chaos, it might a quiet boring game.
~Enjoy~

Well if Saturn used Alex as a shield because he disliked him, wouldn't that make Saturn innocent?

We can't assume that, Speck. Saturn disliking Alex wouldn't mean he knew Alex was mafia.

Wait. How does this shield thing work?

Well in Hunger Games, Zach had a role that allowed him to target someone else if he was killed in any way. He used that person as a shield, and ended up killing two mafia members using his power.

Ohh okay.

I think what it really means is that since I tried to vote him out yesterday until I felt bad about it, and a fellow mafia member would never push to get another mafia member voted out on the first day of the game, I am CLEARLY a mafia member.

5 hours

saturnlite88 wrote:I think what it really means is that since I tried to vote him out yesterday until I felt bad about it, and a fellow mafia member would never push to get another mafia member voted out on the first day of the game, I am CLEARLY a mafia member.

Solid logic. I vote Saturn.


Don't count that vote, Mary. I'm watching you.

I still think there's a good chance that Saturn and PinkSponge are innocent, like I said before, since they both placed a vote for Alex.

As for Boxtop, I think it's a lead but I would feel uncomfortable voting for him. I agreed with him when he said that voting for Alex (who had no evidence as to being a mafia member) seemed like bullying since the reason was "he never helps the town anyways".

I can see why you would want me to be a lead, because right now I think we still don't really have anything. But defending Alex for a good reason and him later turning out mafia shouldn't make me a lead. Just like it's possible to be suspicious of an innocent (it happens everyday), it's possible to not be suspicious of someone guilty.

saturnlite88 wrote:I think what it really means is that since I tried to vote him out yesterday until I felt bad about it, and a fellow mafia member would never push to get another mafia member voted out on the first day of the game, I am CLEARLY a mafia member.

Saturn is obviously using his reverse psychology skills on us so I vote Saturn

Voting for Saturn
Skylar

As much as I still hold a grudge against Saturn for voting me out in my first game, I HATE voting out people on zero evidence. I also don't want to use another "no-vote", but I don't know who to vote for yet

Okay, all caught up. Anyways, I feel like lots of the accusations revolve around one's relationship with another. Perhaps there is someone who strongly dislikes someone else, but is not exploiting them because they are both members of the mafia.
Otherwise, I have no way to figure out what to do, so I no vote until I can think of something better.

Voting for Saturn
Skylar

No Vote
Sawybean1

It's a horribly weak reason, but if we've got nothing else, I think that shad0w would be a kind of safe bet.
She did some stuff that I'm a little iffy on.

shad0wkissed wrote:

boxtop wrote:I've read through the thread so far and I'm not finding anyone suspicious, including the two people being voted for. I'm concerned that people are voting for Alex because they see him as a "useless townie". First off, if the town really wants to win, we need to keep as much of us alive, regardless of playing styles..

Well said! I agree.

Did Alex just make a reference to himself being a pony? Mind of the innocent. Keep him alive, I'd say he's fine.

She pretty much piggybacked off of what boxtop was saying and then came up with a flimsy reason to bolster his image of innocence.

shad0wkissed wrote:I've never done this before and I feel bad for pointing fingers when there's no evidence!! I vote Speckleasme. O.o

She says she doesn't like pointing fingers with no evidence, then goes ahead and votes with no evidence. I brought this up yesterday, I know, but it still doesn't sit right with me.

I vote shad0wkissed.

Voting for Saturn
Skylar

Voting for Shad0wkissed
Pinksponge

No Vote
Sawybean1