Nerdfighter Mafia

Well I agree with you PinkSponge, all of that seemed a little weird to me, but that might be just because she's new. (Or the fact that she was voting for ME )

I think there's a chance Boxtop had ulterior motives for guiding the votes away from Alex... I know other people thought we should let him be, but the fact that Alex did turn out mafia just makes Boxtop more suspicious to me. Sorry, but I vote Boxtop.

I think I'm going to vote boxtop

I think I'm gonna have to go with Shadow on this one. Pink pointed it out well enough.

Boxtop was honestly just sticking up for Alex against me. There wasn't any evidence against Alex so I don't think Boxtop is the most suspicious... today.

I feel like Shad0w is new so she doesn't completely know what she's doing but I do find that suspicious since she was agreeing with what someone said that (possibly unintentionally) defended a mafia member. I vote Shad0w.

I'm going to repeat myself although I doubt it'll do anything. I defended Alex not because I thought he wasn't mafia, but because people were voting for him with no evidence. Him being mafia doesn't change the fact that Pink and Saturn voted for him simply because they thought he wasn't helpful. Him being mafia doesn't mean a townie couldn't have stood up for a person whom he thought was being treated unfairly, regardless of his role. After all, the people voting for him wanted him out regardless of his role.

I am going to go see a movie and won't be back until voting ends. I feel that the arguments against both people are weak, since they seem like they were genuinely defending alex, and I don't want to use another no-vote, so I vote pink sponge This is a random vote, and I don't expect anybody to follow me. I just don't want to use a no-vote and I don't really find pink suspicious.

I just think that the second quote Pink found is the most suspicious. I mean, since when do you find such close direct contradiction? I vote Shadow

Looking at the quote again, I'm not sure it is a contradiction. It says "I don't like having to do this, but I think I have to so I do it." That sorta thing.

Now I'm not as sure as I was.

Lkun wrote:I am going to go see a movie and won't be back until voting ends. I feel that the arguments against both people are weak, since they seem like they were genuinely defending alex, and I don't want to use another no-vote, so I vote pink sponge This is a random vote, and I don't expect anybody to follow me. I just don't want to use a no-vote and I don't really find pink suspicious.

I know it's random but I thought Pinksponge might be one of the most assured innocents. I vote Lkun

1 hour. Applezach's vote didn't count.
Voting for Saturn
Skylar

Voting for Shad0wkissed
Pinksponge
Saturnlite88
Statefarm
Speckleasme

Voting for Boxtop
Partinobodycular

Voting for Pinksponge
Lkun

Voting for Lkun
Decemberhare

No Vote
Sawybean1

WHy not? Is it a game thing?

He didn't bold it.

You don't have to bold your vote. It didn't count because of reasons that he should know.

Maybe it's some sort of restriction of his own role, or someone else was able to decide to stop his voting today.

Oh my, how intense. :O

Guys, I have not been getting enough sleep lately so if I'm more annoying and off-topic than usual, that's why.

I think his vote would have caused a tie? Maybe that's why.

(a tie at that time, I mean)

I think the argument for boxtop is rather weak; I may find Alex annoying, but I wouldn't kill him just for that. Also, Shad0w did contradict herself a bit, but winryrockabell did that exact thing in the Apocalypse game, but was just inexperienced. If nothing better comes up, that evidence is better than nothing, but I'm not sold yet. I'm going to vote Whoviancrochet, because I don't want to vote for shad0w or boxtop, but don't want to no-vote.

What Taylor said about Zach's role makes sense. Does anyone know which alignment that role is generally given to?

There's no role like it that I can find on MafiaScum but I imagine a vote that doesn't allow you to cause a tie could go either way. If you were mafia, it could be negative for not letting you cause a tie against two town members or as town, it could be positive for doing the same thing.

welp i Know why My Vote didnt count
not Sure I want It to Now though

Alright...I've thought about this a bit and I'm going to no-vote again today. I'm still not suspicious enough of anyone to vote for them. I agree with what Saturn said, Shadow's vote looked more like an accidental contradiction than one that a mafia member might make. She might be guilty, but I personally wouldn't base my vote on that.

I don't actually want to vote for Saturn at the moment. I figured more discussion would happen today, and we would possibly get more info/evidence on someone. I'm not totally convinced on the people that are being voted on but its wayyyy better than anything I had for voting Saturn. The whole shadow thing didn't really bother me that much, I think she just didn't want to use a no-vote. I'm also torn between no-voting, and keeping my vote on Saturn, just because it won't do anything to him.

Well, I feel like someone stopped Zach from voting against Boxtop today. And that makes Boxtop look that much worse. Since I don't really want to keep voting Shadow

I vote boxtop.

Unless that ties it or something... I'll check.