Nerdfighter Mafia

Well, nerdfighters, today will go down as the day that nerdfighters lost their heads. Everyone knows that between a puppy sized elephant and an elephant sized puppy, a puppy sized elephant is always the best because it has the evolutionary advantage of being adorable. However, today, nerdfighters were blinded by their grief, confusion and rage and all decided to team up on an adorable puppy sized elephant named Boxtop. Luckily, just as the noose was being tightened, the nerdfighters realized the horrible mistake they were about to make and cut the noose, letting Boxtop free. Then, they all cuddled his adorableness.

Nobody died. You have 12 hours to PM me.

Oh, awesome. We get his innocence confirmed without having to kill him.

Now c'mere, you.

...is there an elephant sized puppy in the mafia?

No, elephant sized puppies are cute and adorable and would never be mafia.

PinkSponge wrote:Oh, awesome. We get his innocence confirmed without having to kill him.

Now c'mere, you.

Except now, the mafia is probably gonna come after me so if there is A DOCTOR IN THE HOUSE, it would probably be smart to protect me as well.

BOXTOP I'M SO SORRY! Also, how could I not realize that you were the most adorable creature to roam the planet?
Can you forgive me?

Puppy sized elephants don't hold grudges.

By the way, now you guys know why I wanted a tie. I didn't want a night where nothing was accomplished.

Feel free to say nothing, Boxtop, but was that a power of yours or someone else's?

Either way it was cool, thanks man.

Update on votes, let me know if there are any inaccuracies.

Good morning, nerdfighters! It's Sunday and things are starting to look up on Nerdfighteria Island. After there not being a lynch last night, the Nerdfighters went to bed, hesitant because they knew that evil still lurked. They left their houses and began checking up on each other to make sure that all of their friends were still alive. Finally, all the heads were counted and the Nerdfighters discovered that none other than Evil Baby Hitler, or Pinksponge, had been murdered overnight. Ideally, Evil Baby Hitler would have been kidnapped and taken to the Evil Baby Orphanage to be raised not to be evil, but his death is still a victory for the town.

Pinksponge, a mafia, is dead. You have 12 hours to lynch someone.

So did the mafia attack that person again? The same one who killed Alex?

I... did not see that coming. I would think the mafia attacked the same person again. I was pretty convinced she was innocent so I feel like the person targeted kills their attacker rather than choosing a shield.

frostehh wrote:Okay the two options are no good. I will break the tie later if it comes to that, but for now unless some evidence comes up, I'm going to do something that might not make sense to everyone...or anyone. My gut feeling about Pinksponge has been wrong every single time. I have gone after her when she was innocent and I have tried my very best to keep her alive when she was mafia. So right now my gut tells me she is innocent. I vote Pinksponge.

Also, from now on, I will always listen to the opposite of Frostehh's gut about PinkSponge.

So Parti's conspiracy theory about PinkSponge handing us Shad0w on a silver platter isn't that far-fetched.

Well that makes me suspicious of Saturn and Parti.

I'm a little suspicious of Parti too since she's actually done that same thing before in a mafia game on Skype. Of course, I guess that could make her less suspicious for thinking it. If I remember correctly, she had also been against Boxtop every day. I would have to check that though.

So maybe that explains why no one really resisted the lynching of Shad0w. It was the mafia's plan all along.

OH MY GOD I WAS RIGHT. I guess it pays to be crazy. I don't see why coming up with that theory makes me suspicious, though. And I don't really know where DecemberHare got Saturn's name from.

I was having fun.

This is good
I think we should look at the people who voted for Matt day one. Pink and alex (both mafia) voted for him along with Saturn and parti.

I vote parti.
I think she told us about pinks plan because she knew she was going to kill pink at night, which would reveal that pink was in fact mafia so she could gain our trust.

I think it's weird that Parti would say that and it would be the exact thing that happened. She also phrased it in a way that made it seem completely ridiculous. I vote Parti.

Voting for Partinobodycular
Skylar
Statefarm

Why would a mafia member kill another member at this point in the game? The mafia's already hurt, they can't afford to be hurting their own numbers. That would be dumb. I had a lucky guess, is all. I also highly doubt the mafia all voted together on day one. I phrased my theory in a way that sounded completely ridiculous because it was, in fact, completely ridiculous. It also happened to be true. That was luck.

Also, for the record, I wasn't online last night from six hours before voting closed to about noon today. I couldn't have sent in a kill, so I couldn't have backstabbed PinkSponge like Skylar suggests I did. I think it's more likely that Pink was killed because of her target.

Okay, so I'm just going to keep talking to myself, I guess. I looked back at the first day's votes. The three people with votes were Matt, speckleasme, and PinkSponge. The mafia wouldn't want to vote for one of their own, so they probably split their votes between Matt and speck. December, Matt, and shad0w voted for speck. We know Matt was innocent and shad0w was mafia. December is unconfirmed. The next day, she voted for Lkun because he voted for PinkSponge:

DecemberHare wrote:

Lkun wrote:I am going to go see a movie and won't be back until voting ends. I feel that the arguments against both people are weak, since they seem like they were genuinely defending alex, and I don't want to use another no-vote, so I vote pink sponge This is a random vote, and I don't expect anybody to follow me. I just don't want to use a no-vote and I don't really find pink suspicious.

I know it's random but I thought Pinksponge might be one of the most assured innocents. I vote Lkun

We know Pink was mafia. Yesterday, December was suspicious of me for being the first person not to vote for shad0w. Does that make any kind of sense to anyone? Now, today, she's suspicious of me because I saw through a really devious plan. Think about it. Who would want to punish me for being too clever? The mafia. I vote DecemberHare.